ART-PRESENTATION: Cybernetics of the Poor

The exhibition “Cybernetics of the Poor: Tutorials, Exercises and Scores” is named after the international seminar that took place in 2019 and was shared between Vienna and San Sebastian. The exhibition raises important issues and invites us to see how artists approach these through their practice. It also invites us to consider the different possible types of response to the processes of planning, anticipation and systematisation that give shape to the world in which we live and define the space left to art or the individual, by this absolute domination of cybernetics which reaches virtually every aspect of our daily lives.

By Dimitris Lempesis
Photo: Tabakalera Archive

The exhibition “Cybernetics of the Poor: Tutorials, Exercises and Scores” combines historical positions and proposals that respond to the new situation where cybernetics is no longer just a concept of power but also one of profit, with both coming together in the notion of control and anticipation through collected data. Four contemporary artists respond to this situation in various ways and have produced new work for this show. But there  are also many classical or lesser known practitioners who had an interest in this, some of them 50 years ago. They have in common that their work falls under one or more of the three categories: Tutorials, Exercises and Scores—the subtitle of  this show. Camila Sposati  works on the border of sculpture and musical instruments, understanding her objects as containers for future use, a use that does not necessarily need to happen in reality but can be defined potentially as  a possible (musical) use that is not random, but is also not predetermined, in that way opposing the culture of pre-sets and apps. Lili Reynaud-Dewar addresses the architectural and institutional logic of museums and other sites of contemporary culture. This French artist, with a history in performance art, film, literature and especially the history of Queer and Afro-Diasporic themes, dances around and inside buildings, transgressing their functional limits. The way the building anticipates and cybernetically regulates gazes, views and movements is countered not with an anarchist gesture but with a language of dance moves and the alien intrusion of a naked, painted, female body moving in a very specific way, exercising an anti-plan by using well defined elements of the dance lexicon without score, drama or an audience. Jon Mikel Euba  explores the ways in which language structures the body. For a number of years, as an extension to his sculptural work, Euba has also been writing. In his practice, thinking about exercise is to think about the ways in which language and body determine each other through a kind of mutual contagion. With this piece, produced specifically in the context of the exhibition. Agency is an artistic initiative based in Brussels whose  work involves analysing the legal framework within which artists work. In this way, it provides a response to the cyber capitalist regime in the very place where the basic concepts of intellectual and creative property are defined. Within the framework of this exhibition, the ambitious proposal is to revisit a total of more than 100 cases of collective activity classified in its archive. Those related to the fan phenomenon are among the most outstanding. The work represents the redefinition of the creative subject as an agent intersected by all kinds of anonymous and impersonal authorities.

The exhibition also shows other contemporary artists who regularly react in one way or another to the challenge of cybernetic control and economy. Constanze Ruhm has made several feature films that are based on the continuation of the life stories of female fictional characters. The many parts of this series of films finally arrive at the question of death and the possibility of burial, a final death of the programmatic potentiality of the troubled surviving characters—figures that have human fates and are ideological and programmatic abstractions in a human form: the raw material of cyber capitalism. Ana de Almeida and Alicja Rogalska have been working for a while on role plays, feminist versions of so called LARPs, Live-Action-Role Plays. They will do a version of the game and also present the results within the exhibition. Some artists are represented by scores and/or work based on scores. The score represents a social programme that has to deal with the dialectics of control and openness, and does so in an exemplary way that is different from the dominant use of such anticipation of human reactions. Cornelius Cardew with his collective The Scratch Orchestra, after experimenting with aleatoric and graphic notation, tried  to directly connect utopian politics with musical practice. Luke Fowler has produced a retrospective essay on this attempt with his film. Anthony Braxton maybe the richest and most wide-reaching innovator of Jazz in the last 50 years, has also tried to notate his musical pieces, performances and operas in different ways, trying to be precise and open at the same time. Alex Mendizabal also highlights   the ability of elements such as sheet music to question the authority granted to an institution such as the orchestra. For orchestra is the result  of an obsessive exercise which began with the simple aim of producing a quantity of compositions per day. Don Van Vliet better known by his stage name Captain Beefheart, did not write scores, but often explained that his turn from music to painting was not a silencing; he understood his paintings to be “very loud”, as a visual statement of an interpretation, a reading that should be heard. Noa Eshkol was a dancer and dance instructor who was deeply interested in cybernetics and a good friend of Heinz von Foerster, who introduced her to NASA. The space programmes were able use her knowledge of dance and body movements and her unique notation method.

Sharon Lockhart, who was also important for the rediscovery of Eshkol, has photographed the three-dimensional, “sculptural” notation system of Eshkol. The work “Scale” by Elena Asins  also arises from the artist’s inexhaustible interest in all kinds of notation systems and their application to the plastic arts as a way of restricting the quality of the personal to the minimum. The notion of a computational art, referred to by Asins at different times, demonstrates a radical questioning of the separation between mechanical and sensitive exercise. Jorge Oteiza is known, among other things, for his unfinished projects, makes a foray into musical composition through scores created out loud with his own voice, proposing a first rehearsal without an orchestra in which the artist reveals himself to be a great ventriloquist capable of occupying and interchanging different positions and sound registers. Jörg Schlick used the beginning of the Human Genome Code after it had been documented by a German newspaper (filling their entire cultural section and applied it  in the organization of photographs. He used the code as an organizational tutorial by applying it to something completely different, demonstrating the randomness but also the beauty of organizational systems and their potentials. Hanne Darboven  has done something similar in her life work  of writings and drawings that follow strict organizational systems which function for her like self-ordered laws or rules, replacing social control not by its opposite, but by a different, self-developed set of rules. These kinds of projects often grew out of conceptual practices. Less serious on a superficial level, but very philosophical, are the projects by Douglas Huebler, among them a series of photographs showing every human being on earth.. Similarly the photographer Heinrich Riebesehl,  who had no background in conceptual art, took a series of photographs in an elevator of the publishing house he worked for in the German city of Hannover in the 1960s. He portrayed people as if he was a surveillance camera—long before such a thing came into existence. The work “The Rescue of the Ear and the Moustache”  (2016) by Gema Intxausti also refers to control and surveillance techniques. Although in this case the action takes the form of an exploration of the Stasi Museum in Berlin. The locus of many of the artists in this exhibition is situated between a score and an exercise. Peter Roehr tried to capture the monotony and minimalist charm of the controlled life in a consumer society. He left behind several hundred works in which he exclusively pursued the idea of serial repetition. The work of Mike Kelley is characterised, by exploring the psychopathological dimension of cyber capitalism in a singular way through the manipulation of the most common objects. The two-channel video that we present in this exhibition documents an installation with a markedly theatrical character, in which visitors to an exhibition by the artist are invited to interact with objects displayed in an enclosed space.

Participant artists: Agency, Jon Mikel Euba, Lili Reynaud-Dewar, Camila Sposati, Constanze Ruhm, Ana de Almeida & Alicja Rogalska, Gema Intxausti, Luke Fowler, Alex Mendizabal, Sharon Lockhart, Cory Arcangel and Pedro G. Romero.

Works by: Don Van Vliet, Cornelius Cardew, Anthony Braxton, Elena Asins, Hanne Darboven, Edgar Degas, Jörg Schlick, Peter Roehr, Douglas Huebler, Heinrich Riebesehl, Mike Kelley and others.

Info: Tabakalera, Andre zigarrogileak plaza 1, Donostia-San Sebastian, Duration: 6/3-23/8/20, Days & Hours: Mon-Thu 9:00-21:00, Fri 9:00-22:00, Sat 10:00-22:00, Sun 10:00-21:00, www.tabakalera.eu